cross-posted from: https://lemmy.ca/post/72669678
In a paper published in Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems, Dr. Chris Macdonald explored the best sources of protein currently available.
To answer the question, Macdonald had to build a new holistic scoring system that combines measures of environmental impact, health, affordability and availability into a single framework.
Applying the scoring system to 20 commonly consumed protein-rich foods, the analysis found a striking pattern: every product in the highest-scoring quintile was plant-based, while every product in the lowest-scoring quintile was animal-based. Tofu ranked first overall, while cheddar cheese ranked last.
The paper argues that many existing food rating systems focus on only one aspect of a product. While useful, these single-dimension labels can obscure important trade-offs and make it difficult to compare foods comprehensively.
TOFU DOMINATION
Link to open access article https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/sustainable-food-systems/articles/10.3389/fsufs.2026.1677796/full
once again, poore-nemecek 2018 is being used to prop up “research”
why do these studies always ignore other vegan meat alternatives like TVP?
Sure tofu is great for those who like it, but TVP is basically just the same thing made with a different process and the result is incomparably more palatable to me. TVP is quite literally just plant meat.
I feel like there’s a weird elitism around tofu, as if eating it makes you superior even to someone who just eats regular vegetables…I like soy curls even more than TVP
TVP=Textured Vegetable Proteins for those wondering.
This. Tofu is gross but TVP is basically a perfect sub for ground beef.
Except it has a shelf life of forever, it’s cheap as hell, and very fast to prepare.
Surprisingly absent from the study is packaging?
I can buy TVP and flour in bulk from bring-your-own-bag shops. I can’t do that with tofu. It’s a lot of plastic waste.
Guess they didn’t consider taste.
Seitan all day.
This. Seitan is just superior! (Also, it is as close to “pure protein” as a food can get)
Though tofu is the best of soy-based meat alternatives. Everything else tastes extremely meh.
I prefer tvp to tofu, depending on the use (eg with pasta). Both are soy
Well, clearly Chris McDonald didn’t have a farm with animals on it.
Chris McDonald is a awesome. Be like Chris McDonald.
Here is their website: betterproteininstitute.com
And here are the results: https://www.betterproteininstitute.com/_files/ugd/7be592_a59b2ddfe5a746afa23d19a4583964cb.pdf
Thanks.
Really disappointing that seitan and tvp are entirely absent.
Does McDonald have a TOFU farm or something?
i unironically think there’s some sort of industry conspiracy to suppress meat alternatives that would actually become popular, it’s the only thing that makes sense considering just how bizarre the situation is.
Companies in america have been using TVP to replace bacon in salads for YEARS because it’s literally cheaper, but somehow here in sweden it’s literally not available in stores? Make it make sense.
Here’s there website, but clickable
So this recipe is ranked in the middle.
Or you could just skip the cheese and sprinkle nutritional yeast sauce (sunflower seeds and lemon) on it instead?
A fine comprimise
Surprised and sad to see cheese getting a bad score. Avoiding cheese is not easy.
don’t worry about it. this is just bad science from 2018 in a new wrapper
Really? What things can’t you just order without cheese?
A lot of Italian places the only non meat option is going to lean heavy on cheese.
Also Pizza
Lol wut. Pizza is like the easiest thing. The dough 90% of the time is vegan.
Just tell them not to put cheese on it.
Protip: ask for extra tomato sauce.
Can’t order cheese without cheese. In some places, there’s a dedicated cheese course, usually after main course or desert, with a plate of cheese to share. That’s how I eat most cheese.
Makes sense, every step up the food chain is rough, even if you don’t have to kill the animal to harvest.
Plus there’s the whole forced-breeding-baby-abduction-and-slaughter thing…
If you’re eating cheese as a protein source, you’re doing it wrong.
Why? It’s about twice as dense in protein as tofu.
It comes along with loads of saturated fat, cholesterol, salt.
there are some brands of vegan cheese that are actually perfectly acceptable, the one i tried can even melt properly if you handle it right.
(i think it, like, needs enough mass? maybe it’s just that having a thick layer of it makes it warm up slower… I had times where it ended up with the fat separating and the starch burning…)I’ll see if I can find some to try. Melted cheese is not my cup of tea, so I don’t care how well it melt.
Tofu may win, but we all lose when we eat it (it’s gross).
I’m kidding, I don’t mind it, I’m just making a stupid joke
Bad jokes aside, this is 100% my new favorite way to prepare tofu:
https://veganscratchkitchen.substack.com/p/crispy-shredded-tofu-chikn
Use it in salads, sandwiches, tacos, soups, bowls, etc.
Seasoning adjusts based on final recipe.
too bad Tofu tastes awful
Agreed. Seitan had a much better texture. And higher protein.
Sounds like a skill issue.
if you need skill to make it enjoyable people aren’t going to eat it
Do you eat a raw unseasoned chuck roast? Or do you expect someone with skill to make it enjoyable? Millions of people enjoy tofu daily, so clearly it’s not hard, I cam share recipes if you’re interested in learning a skill.
It’s honestly not the taste for me. It’s easy enough to cover up with sauces. The real issue for me, anyway, has always been the texture. I really have a hard time with anything that’s curdy. It just makes me want to vomit. Maybe I was exposed to too much bad milk at some point I don’t really remember…not sure. And the more dense and dry the curds are, the more difficult it is to ignore.
That said I do enjoy the soft, silky kind of tofu. It’s more like a gelatin than a rancid milk left sitting out for days kind of feeling.
I just watched a video about this and it was counter to the advice I normally see here (press it forever): boil for 5 minutes in salted water and let dry on a rack for several minutes. My wife (Japanese) was like “oh yeah, that’s the right way to do it; I’m just too lazy”. Like, I never knew this since I love to cook and do most of the cooking anyway so it just never came up until I put the video on.
The video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hfRCZBWT4a0&t=893s
this is why i will die on the hill that TVP is the best invention since fire. It’s basically tofu but immediately enjoyable, it just inherently has a meaty texture.
I used to dislike tofu because of its texture, but after I learned to freeze it and then press it, I love it. Shallowfried till crispy and seasoned (in that order) it has become a 1-1 substitute for chicken breast. The taste isn’t the same, but it adds the same to a dish that chicken does.
Try a tofu cutlet or pressed tofu, much less curdy
Freeze it, thaw it, squeeze the water out, and either boil it or marinade it. It will take on the taste of whatever you cook it with.
https://veganscratchkitchen.substack.com/p/crispy-shredded-tofu-chikn
This is my new favorite - shred, season, spread, bake.
No need to press or freeze








