• 0 Posts
  • 2 Comments
Joined 5 months ago
cake
Cake day: June 22nd, 2026

help-circle
  • @nfreak @SocialistVibes01 I still think that the idea was good. NASA helps these companies with their knowledge and grants access to their facilities to test stuff like for example heat shields. On the other hand these companies aren’t hanging on a brittle liveline that NASA has to fight for every four years.

    Just have a look at Constellation/SLS. This program is completely driven by politics and less by what would be possible. AFAIK some people call it the “Senate Launch System” for a good reason.

    It would had been better to define the goals first, then to ask NASA for their needed budget and then have the senate to decide if they will approve it. But that’s not how US politics work, I think.


  • @admin @uberdroog Most likely ULA’s problem was caused by an underperforming booster - and that is powered by two engines from Blue Origin. The rocket itself already proved that it can deliver payload into an orbit - even with partially failing solid rocket boosters. This means that the whole concept itself is well constructed.

    With Starship things are different. They still have to prove that they can transport the estimated payload capacity into space. Their first orbital testflight proved that a partially loaded Starship can be brought up into space and back (which is quite an achievment) but the booster failed to return to the launch site because the fuel was empty. And Starship hadn’t been at their maximum payload.

    You can’t beat physics. And the rocket equation really is hard to beat.